Turkey Earthquake: Lessons from a disaster for the built environment

 

The scale of devastation caused by the earthquake in Turkey and Syria has raised questions about the safety of built structures

 
By Fahad Mohamed, February 22, 2023 UAE IFM
 

Turkey Earthquake: Lessons from a disaster for the built environment
 

Natural disasters cannot be prevented but the impact due to natural disasters can be softened to a great extent. The recent earthquake in Turkey and the consequent damages that have caused numerous buildings to collapse is a serious cause of concern for all professionals working in the built environment industry, starting from manufacturing materials, and contracting to maintenance. All through every part of the built environment life cycle, this aspect of safety and reliability can be questioned.

Building codes are usually enhanced or improved once a serious incident takes place, but even though there are strict codes in place, do all follow them or is it even cascaded down to the person who is expected to implement the same? Post such damage, do we hold the contractors or consultants who have contributed to the mishap accountable? Do we have the answer to these questions? The inquiries will go on, but somewhere down the line, the realisation may strike some - making safe structures and maintaining the safety of such structures should indeed be the priority of any built environment professional.

The aftermath in Turkey has now forced the local regulatory authorities to deep dive into the codes and practices used in construction as well as maintenance. Many contractors are now under scrutiny as well, but this does not immediately help the lost lives as well as lost shelters. Re-building is time-consuming, painstaking and cost-intensive, so prevention is the best cure.

Not all areas may be prone to earthquakes, but it may happen due to ever-changing geology of the landmass. On the other hand, some areas have accepted earthquakes as part of their daily routine - countries such as Japan come to mind. Japan is located along the Pacific Ring of Fire, which is an area where numerous tectonic plates meet. Thus, building earthquake-resistant structures and maintaining them is vital for safeguarding the Japanese population. There are other countries too who sit on locations with high seismic activity such as Indonesia, China, the United States, Mexico, and New Zealand.

It is important to note that the number of earthquakes alone is not the only indicator of seismic threat to a country. Factors such as population density, building codes and infrastructure, and emergency response capabilities also play a substantial role in determining the level of risk posed by earthquakes.

We can look at Japan as an example since it has been through numerous and terrifying earthquakes and certain ways they have adopted can be used as best practices. The aspects that should be looked at are:

  • Strictest building codes in the world – especially on seismic safety.
  • Isolating the base – separating the building from the base by using bearings and shocks
  • Strong and Flexible structure – The use of diagonal braces, cross walls, and reinforced concrete.
  • Regular inspections and high-quality maintenance – regular stringent inspections are in place to ensure codes are practiced and any damages are repaired immediately. Also, regular high-quality maintenance is put into practice by the building owners.
  • Education and awareness – Strong emphasis is laid out starting from the school age to workplaces to consistently provide awareness and education on the risks and mitigation measures for earthquakes.

If we give a closer look at the five points mentioned above, it is clear that Japan has led the way by taking a holistic approach to the building environment starting from stringent regulations, innovative design, quality construction, efficient maintenance regime, regular inspections, and emphasis on education.

As a built environment professional and regardless of the geographical boundaries, it is a professional need for us to be involved in various phases of the building lifecycle to ensure risks related to seismic activities are managed. The various aspects may be:

  1. Improving and innovating efficient building designs through regular operational feedback.
  2. Create provisions to provide periodic feedback to local regulators and lawmakers to create more safe environments. This can be achieved through special interest groups and public forums.
  3. Vigilant evaluation of building testing & commissioning (with relevant emphasis on structural aspects).
  4. Strong maintenance regimes are to be followed on civil and structural parts of the building through planned and condition-based improvement methods.
  5. Stringent and regular inspections both using destructive and in-destructive tests, leading to immediate rectification.
  6. Consistent awareness to stakeholders such as lawmakers, business heads, influencers, workforce, homemakers

Note by the author: I would like to express my condolences and sympathy for the families who have lost deeply due to the recent earthquake in Turkey and Syria. It is not easy to lose people or properties as these form an integral part of our lives.

 

This article was authored by Eng. Fahad Mohamed, Director – Dubai & Northern Emirates, Adeeb Group, as part of the 'Expert Talk' series. Built Environment's ‘Expert Talk’ series carries knowledge pieces every week by industry professionals who give their take on the key trends, observations, issues, and challenges in the built industry. The opinions in these articles are the author's own and do not reflect that of the publication. This is a standard disclaimer.

Turkey  Syria  earthquake  building collapse  Turkey death-toll  building safety  building codes  code enforcement  safe structures  efficient building design  seismic activity  construction  efficient maintenance regime  earthquake-proof  

MORE FROM BUILT ENVIRONMENT

Mohamed Alabbar on Building a Successful Brand in Real Estate: Quality and Authenticity
Mohamed Alabbar on Building a Successful Brand in Real Estate: Quality and Authenticity

The CEO and Managing Director of Emaar Properties provided insights into building a successful business venture at the 1 Billion Followers Summit 2025

January 15, 2025 UAE Real Estate
Dubai Land Department Urges Property Owners to Join Owners Committees
Dubai Land Department Urges Property Owners to Join Owners Committees

RERA notes that Owners Committees present an excellent opportunity for property owners to contribute to building thriving and sustainable communities aligned with the values of innovation and Dubai’s ambitious vision

January 15, 2025 UAE Community Management
Nakheel partners with six renowned architecture firms to design 10 bespoke Beach Collection villas on Palm Jebel Ali
Nakheel partners with six renowned architecture firms to design 10 bespoke Beach Collection villas on Palm Jebel Ali

Nakheel’s projects form an iconic portfolio of master communities and residential developments that are pivotal to realising Dubai’s vision

January 15, 2025 UAE Real Estate
Capital Central Park: Egypt's Green Heartbeat in the New Administrative Capital
Capital Central Park: Egypt's Green Heartbeat in the New Administrative Capital

A transformative urban park project in Egypt’s New Administrative Capital, designed to promote sustainability, cultural heritage, and community well-being through innovative green infrastructure.

January 15, 2025 Egypt Sustainability
Lacasa Living Unveil Ola Residences at Al Marjan Island
Lacasa Living Unveil Ola Residences at Al Marjan Island

The boutique residences are anticipated to be ready for handover in the first quarter of 2027

January 14, 2025 UAE Real Estate
ENGIE Solutions Secures Major FM Contract for DMCC's Uptown Tower
ENGIE Solutions Secures Major FM Contract for DMCC's Uptown Tower

ENGIE Solutions will provide mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and HVAC systems management, along with specialized technical services vital to maintaining the building's world-class standards.

January 13, 2025 UAE IFM
Waslat Anticipates Five-Fold Revenue Increase by 2028
Waslat Anticipates Five-Fold Revenue Increase by 2028

The platform strengthens Saudi Arabia’s real estate offering with cutting-edge AI solutions, empowering over 750,000 users

January 13, 2025 Saudi Arabia PropTech
The Changing Face of UAE Coworking: Adapting to Market Demands
The Changing Face of UAE Coworking: Adapting to Market Demands

Coworking spaces have expanded beyond freelancers and startups, attracting large enterprises, multinational corporations, and hybrid teams

January 13, 2025 UAE Property Management
Emicool Partners with Quant Gulf to Launch AI-Driven Predictive Maintenance for Enhanced Cooling Efficiency
Emicool Partners with Quant Gulf to Launch AI-Driven Predictive Maintenance for Enhanced Cooling Efficiency

A pilot phase was initially conducted at one of Emicool’s flagship plants, demonstrating the OPTIME Ecosystem’s remarkable benefits, such as reduced operational costs, improved efficiency, and greater energy optimization

January 12, 2025 UAE IFM
Dubai Real Estate Sector Hits New Peak, with 180,900 Transactions Worth AED522.1 billion
Dubai Real Estate Sector Hits New Peak, with 180,900 Transactions Worth AED522.1 billion

The transaction volume surged by 51% to 119,800 in 2024, reflecting a substantial increase in buyer confidence and developer activity

January 7, 2025 UAE Real Estate
 
Subscribe to our newsletter